The Wedding Dossier · Wedding Cakes · Florida

30 cake makers in Tallahassee, FL

30 cake makers around Tallahassee and Ocala, Lake City, Cedar Key, Gainesville, Hastings and 4 more nearby towns, each checked against its own website and verified as a wedding business. Not a top ten.

9 of them (30%) publish their pricing. Their listings show the real numbers. The other 21 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Tallahassee cake maker we're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it. Is one of these your business? See your listing and certify it.

Wedding Cakes pricing in Florida
Typical per-serving range
$7/serving–$9/serving
Market range
$3/serving–$47/serving
Publish pricing
51of 620

Florida wedding cake bakers typically charge $7 to $9 per serving, with the full market range spanning $3 to $47 per serving. These figures reflect only the vendors who publish pricing online; premium and luxury bakers tend to require an inquiry instead, so the true market average is likely higher.

The Tallahassee cake makers list

Showing 20 of 30 cake makers

  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Ocala

    Nothing Bundt Cakes specializes in custom Bundt cakes in various sizes and flavors, available for weddings and celebrations. They offer tiered cakes, decorated options, and delivery services in the Ocala, FL area.

    $39/serving – $43/serving

    Individual cakes priced per serving; catering services available with $75 minimum order but no per-guest wedding pricing stated.

    modernelegantcustomizable
    nothingbundtcakes.com(352) 517-72763411 SW 36th Terrace Suite 2, Ocala, FL, 34474

  • Artistic Confections Inc.

    Tallahassee

    Artistic Confections specializes in luxury custom wedding cakes in Tallahassee, Florida, with personalized consultations and fresh-baked ingredients. The bakery has been serving the area since 2011 with a focus on unique, delicious, and perfectly executed custom designs.

    from $6/serving

    Wedding cake pricing stated as per-serving rate with potential surcharges for flavors.

    luxurycustomelegantpersonalized
    tallahasseecakes.com(850) 577-30003710 Austin Davis Ave Unit 140, Tallahassee, FL 32308, USA

  • Q-Ti Cakes

    Tallahassee

    Q-Ti Cakes is a designer cake boutique in Tallahassee specializing in custom, made-to-order wedding cakes crafted from scratch with fresh ingredients. They offer personalized designs to match each couple's style and taste.

    from $5/serving

    Wedding cake pricing by consultation only; cheesecake slices at $5 per serving and cupcake bouquets at $60 are the only wedding-relevant published prices.

    customdesignerelegantmodernluxury
    qticakes.wixsite.com+ +18504455739

  • Brittany's Cupcake Shoppe

    Lake City

    Brittany's Cupcake Shoppe is a family-owned Lake City bakery specializing in custom cupcakes and gourmet desserts with over 51 flavors in rotation. They offer wedding-specific options including a 'Wedding Cake' cupcake flavor and custom orders for events.

    $4/serving – $6/serving

    Retail cupcake pricing by individual item; no wedding-specific pricing stated.

    casualfamily-ownedcustomcontemporary
    brittanyscupcakeshoppe.com(386) 628-6115857 SW Main Blvd #125, Lake City, FL 32025, USA

  • Pink and Sweet Bakery and Restaurant

    Ocala

    Pink and Sweet Bakery and Restaurant offers custom cakes and a variety of desserts including cheesecake, macarons, and specialty cakes. They operate as a full-service bakery and restaurant with delivery available in the Ocala area.

    $6/serving – $7/serving

    Cake slice pricing is wedding-relevant; macarons and custom cake inquiry are non-wedding retail or inquiry-only.

    casualmodernbakery-focused
    pinkandsweetbakeryandrestaurant1.scvr.co(352) 421-91232515 Northeast 3rd Street, Ocala, Florida, 34470

  • Cedar Key Island Bakery

    Cedar Key

    Cedar Key Island Bakery is a family-owned bakery specializing in fresh-baked goods including whole cakes, pies, and custom desserts made daily with generational recipes. Located on Cedar Key Island, Florida, they offer whole cakes starting at $55 and emphasize handcrafted quality and fresh ingredients.

    from $8/serving

    Retail cake and slice pricing; no wedding-specific packages or per-guest meal pricing published.

    rustictraditionalhomemadefamily-ownedartisanal
    ckibakery.com(352) 325-3750315 2nd St, Cedar Key, FL 32625, USA

  • Curia On The Drag

    Gainesville

    Curia on the Drag is an eclectic vegan coffee shop and bakery in Gainesville, Florida that offers custom cakes, cupcakes, and other baked goods suitable for weddings and celebrations. They provide custom cake design with multiple flavor and frosting options starting at $30 for smash cakes.

    $8/serving – $11/serving

    Custom wedding cake pricing by serving size; per-serving rates calculated from published cake prices and stated serving ranges.

    veganeclecticmoderncasualgarden
    curiaonthedrag.com(352) 792-64442029 NW 6th St, Gainesville, FL 32609, USA

  • Capital City Cakes, LLC

    Tallahassee

    Capital City Cakes specializes in custom wedding cakes and desserts tailored to your taste and style. Based in Tallahassee, FL, they offer a variety of cake flavors and frosting options for weddings and special events.

    from $165

    Custom wedding cake with $165 minimum; final price varies by size, design complexity, and labor.

    customelegantpersonalized
    capitalcitycakesfl.com(850) 706-1225

  • AngelcakesFL

    Gainesville

    Angel Cakes FL is a custom cake bakery offering multi-tiered wedding cakes, cupcakes, and desserts with extensive flavor and frosting options. Operating for over 10 years, they specialize in made-from-scratch baked goods using high-quality ingredients.

    $50 – $500

    Cake vendor with single/multi-tiered whole-cake pricing; cupcakes and taster cakes are non-wedding retail items.

    customclassicelegant
    angelcakesfl.com(352) 213-1154

  • ChocoLattes

    Hastings

    ChocoLattes is a women-owned bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes, dessert tables, and groom's cakes with gluten-free and vegan options. They require a phone consultation and offer a 30-day minimum lead time for weddings.

    Pricing on request

    Cake pricing available by consultation only; only set-up and delivery fee ($50) is published.

    customartisanalelegantnaturally decorated
    chocolattes47.com(386) 385-8225308 N Main St B, Hastings, FL 32145, USA

  • Reverent & Sweet

    The Villages

    Reverent & Sweet creates handcrafted luxury cakes and cupcakes for weddings and meaningful celebrations, with an emphasis on elegant design and premium ingredients. The business also offers faith-rooted officiant services including wedding ceremonies and vow renewals.

    Pricing on request
    elegantrefinedluxuryfaith-rootedartisanalintentional
    reverentandsweet.com(321) 350-1768

  • Au Péché Mignon French Pastry Shop

    Tallahassee

    Au Péché Mignon is a French pastry shop in Tallahassee that specializes in creating exquisite custom wedding and groom's cakes with elegant European designs. They offer tastings and work with couples to execute custom cake designs for their special day.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing is by consultation with the baker; no published dollar amounts provided.

    elegantEuropeanFrenchsophisticatedcustom
    frenchpastrytallahassee.com(850) 668-5533220 N Duval St, Tallahassee, FL 32301, USA

  • Magnolia Bakery

    Ocala

    Magnolia Bakery is a family-owned Italian bakery in Ocala specializing in custom wedding cakes and elaborate desserts, with over 75 years of experience. They create made-to-order cakes for weddings, anniversaries, and special events based on client designs.

    Pricing on request

    Individual cake prices ($25–$69) are below realistic wedding per-serving levels and lack explicit wedding context.

    classicitaliantraditionalcustomelegant
    magnoliabakeryocala.wixsite.com(352) 207-26671412 N Magnolia Ave, Ocala, FL 34475, USA

  • Tasty Pastry Bakery

    Tallahassee

    Tasty Pastry Bakery specializes in custom cakes for all occasions, including weddings, with decorated expert staff and 60+ years of family baking tradition. They offer personalized designs, multiple cake styles, and complementary desserts for wedding celebrations.

    Pricing on request
    customelegantromanticmodernclassicboho
    tastypastrybakery.com(850) 893-37521355 Market St a3, Tallahassee, FL 32312, USA

  • Tupelo's Bakery & Cafe

    Quincy

    Tupelo's Bakery & Cafe is a locally-owned bakery in Monticello, FL specializing in custom wedding cakes made from scratch with organic, local ingredients. They offer cake tastings and consultations by appointment.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing available by inquiry only; no published prices provided.

    rusticeleganthomemadeorganiclocally-sourced
    tupelosbakery.com(850) 997-2127220 W Washington St, Monticello, FL 32344, USA

  • Uppercrust

    Gainesville

    Uppercrust is an artisan bakery founded in 1981 specializing in fresh-baked cakes, croissants, and custom baked goods. They offer custom cakes with advance notice for weddings and special events.

    Pricing on request

    Individual cake and cupcake retail pricing only; no wedding-specific packages or per-serving wedding cake pricing stated.

    artisanalFrencheleganttraditionalhandcrafted
    uppercrustgnv.com(352) 376-71874118 NW 16th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32605, USA

  • Betty Cakes Cafe

    Ocala

    Betty Cakes Bakery & Cafe specializes in custom wedding cakes and celebration cakes with in-person design consultations. Located in Ocala, Florida, they offer both custom creations and signature shelf cakes available for immediate pickup.

    Pricing on request

    Custom wedding cake pricing available by inquiry only; no published prices.

    customelegantbuttercreamdecorated
    bettycakes.com(352) 622-3727

  • Forgotten Coast Cakes

    Apalachicola

    Forgotten Coast Cakes is a custom cake bakery specializing in wedding cakes, birthday cakes, and cupcakes serving the Florida Panhandle. The in-home baker creates fully custom designs and requires 1-2 weeks notice for orders.

    Pricing on request

    Only a $50 order minimum and delivery fee are stated; no wedding cake pricing is published.

    rusticelegantbohobeach-themedfloralnaked cake
    forgottencoastcakes.com(850) 368-590620 Hammock Cove Rd, Eastpoint, FL 32328, USA

  • Just Celebrate LLC

    Gainesville

    Just Celebrate offers custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, cakesicles, and comprehensive event decor styling in Gainesville, Florida. As a one-stop shop, they provide professional creative services for weddings and special occasions with custom design and execution.

    Pricing on request

    Retail cake and dessert items including custom cakes, cakesicles, cupcakes, and Valentine's-themed products; no wedding-specific pricing stated.

    elegantcustomromanticvintagemodern
    justcelebratefl.com(352) 681-11244127 NW 16th Blvd, Gainesville, FL 32605, USA

  • Smallcakes Tallahassee, FL

    Tallahassee

    Smallcakes Tallahassee is a locally-owned cupcakery offering fresh-baked cupcakes daily with 15 standard flavors plus monthly specialty options. They specialize in custom pull-apart cakes, custom cupcakes, and catering for weddings, birthday parties, and events.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing available only upon request for custom orders; no published prices.

    casualfunplayfulmodern
    smallcakestallahassee.com1480 Apalachee Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32301, USA
Get your shortlist

Which of these 30 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me