9 cake makers in Key West, FL
We tracked down 25 possible cake makers around Key West and Key Largo, Islamorada, Marathon, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 9 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.
2 of them (22%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 7 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.
Know a Key West cake makerwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.
Florida wedding cake bakers typically charge $7 to $9 per serving, with the full market ranging from $3 to $47 per serving. Because premium and luxury bakers rarely publish prices and instead require direct inquiry, this data reflects only vendors who disclose pricing publicly, meaning the true market average is likely higher.
The Key West cake makers list
Pinecrest Bakery - Key Largo
Key LargoPinecrest Bakery is a Cuban bakery chain offering gourmet cakes and catering services with multiple South Florida locations, including Key Largo. They specialize in ready-to-go cakes with 2-3 day advance orders and custom cake designs.
$1/serving – $3/servingGourmet cake pricing stated as total price range with serving count; calculated per-slice rates from $20.79–$46.79 for ~15-slice cakes.
Cubantraditionalgourmettropical flavorsCakes by Karol
Key WestCakes by Karol is a custom wedding cake baker in Key West with over 15 years of experience creating bespoke, artistic cakes tailored to each couple's unique love story. They offer wedding cakes, dessert towers, groom's cakes, and celebration cakes with delivery throughout the Florida Keys.
from $180Minimum order of $180 for cakes and desserts; final pricing varies by customization details.
customartisticbespokeelegantKey West Cakes
Key WestKey West Cakes is an award-winning specialty bakery founded in 2001, dedicated to creating hand-crafted, custom wedding cakes that combine creativity, presentation, and flavor. They offer tastings, custom designs, and a wide variety of cake flavors and fillings tailored to each couple's vision.
Pricing on requestcustomartistichand-craftedspecialtyPastry Mermaid
Key LargoLe Cordon Bleu-trained pastry chef offering custom wedding cakes and desserts with tropical Florida Keys flavors and French patisserie techniques. Gina Johnson creates bespoke confections for weddings and special events throughout the Keys.
Pricing on requestelegantromantictropicalartisanalFrench patisserieluxeCupcake Sushi
Key WestCupcake Sushi offers patented, innovative bite-sized desserts that resemble sushi rolls, made with rolled buttercream, moist cake, and dark chocolate. The company provides custom dessert options for weddings, rehearsal dinners, and special events with nationwide shipping available.
Pricing on requestRetail cupcake box pricing, not wedding-specific cake service.
elegantuniqueartisticgourmetinnovativeThe Trading Post w/Key Lime Pie Lady
IslamoradaKey Lime Pie Lady specializes in handmade, locally-crafted key lime pies available for wedding desserts in the Florida Keys. They offer custom wedding dessert packages and can accommodate special dietary needs with advance notice.
Pricing on requesttraditionalartisanallocally-sourcedhandmadeVicky Bakery Key Largo
Key LargoVicky Bakery Key Largo is a Cuban bakery specializing in custom cakes for weddings and special occasions, with family recipes dating back to 1972. They offer custom cake design and ordering through in-store visits or phone consultation.
Pricing on requestWedding cake pricing available by request only; no published prices.
traditionalcubanartisanalfamily-ownedMattheessen’s Candy Kitchen
Key WestMattheessen's Candy Kitchen is a homemade treats bakery specializing in cookies, fudge, macaroons, and key lime pie, with over 30 years of experience. They explicitly offer special orders for weddings and events.
Pricing on requestartisanalhomemadecasualtraditionalSweet Savannah's of the Florida Keys
MarathonSweet Savannah's is a cupcake and baked goods shop in Marathon, Florida offering custom desserts for special occasions including weddings. They specialize in handcrafted cupcakes, key lime pie, cookies, and other baked goods made fresh daily.
Pricing on requestcasualtropicallocalartisanal
Which of these 9 fit your budget?
Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.
Rank these for me