46 cake makers in Indianapolis, IN

46 cake makers around Indianapolis and Carmel, Anderson, Greenfield, Plainfield, Lebanon and 6 more nearby towns, each checked against its own website and verified as a wedding business. Not a top ten.

2 of them (4%) publish their pricing. Their listings show the real numbers. The other 44 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Indianapolis cake maker we're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it. Is one of these your business? See your listing and certify it.

The Indianapolis cake makers list

Showing 20 of 46 cake makers
  • The Flying Cupcake

    Carmel

    The Flying Cupcake is a Carmel, Indiana bakery specializing in cupcakes and custom cakes, with a dedicated wedding offering that includes tiered cupcake displays, simple cutting cakes, tier rental, delivery, and setup.

    $4/serving – $7/serving
    • Wedding cupcakes: $4.30-$5/guest · Fresh cupcakes, tiered presentation, 30+ flavors
    cupcake-focusedcustombuttercreamplayfultiered
  • Sweet Escape Cake Company

    Indianapolis

    Family-owned Indianapolis bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes, with a private tasting, 19 flavors and 9 fillings included at base price, and delivery/setup across Central Indiana.

    $252 – $1,560
    • Round 2 tier, 36 servings: $252 · buttercream, 8 + 6 tiers
    • Round 2 tier, 36 servings: $270 · fondant, 8 + 6 tiers
    • Round 2 tier, 50 servings: $350 · buttercream, 10 + 6 tiers
    • Round 2 tier, 50 servings: $375 · fondant, 10 + 6 tiers
    • Round 3 tier, 74 servings: $518 · buttercream, 10 + 8 + 6 tiers
    • Round 3 tier, 74 servings: $555 · fondant, 10 + 8 + 6 tiers
    • Round 3 tier, 118 servings: $826 · buttercream, 12 + 10 + 8 tiers
    • Round 3 tier, 118 servings: $885 · fondant, 12 + 10 + 8 tiers
    • Fee: Tasting: $30 · 50 minutes, three flavors and three fillings, up to 3 guests
    • Fee: Delivery and setup: $60 · Friday and Saturday, up to 10 miles
    customclassicromanticrusticbohoelegant
    sweetescapecakecompany.com(317) 840-15627745 S Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46217
  • Butter & Batter Bakery

    Anderson

    Butter & Batter Bakery is a full-service bakery in Lapel, Indiana that creates custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other desserts. It offers a wedding-specific inquiry process, tasting, consultation, and delivery for wedding cakes in central Indiana.

    Pricing on request

    No specific pricing is listed in the provided text.

    customeleganthandcraftedromanticclassicvintage-inspired
    butterandbatterbakery.com609 Main St, Lapel, IN 46051, USA
  • Molly’s Sociable Sweets

    Indianapolis

    Molly’s Sociable Sweets is a Plainfield, Indiana cake studio specializing in custom buttercream wedding cakes and edible cupcake bouquets that can double as floral centerpieces.

    Pricing on request

    The text lists only individual cupcake pricing plus tasting, delivery, and deposit fees, with no wedding cake package or per-serving price.

    elegantcustombuttercreamfloralartisticromantic
  • A Piece of Cake

    Indianapolis

    A Piece of Cake is a Greenwood, Indiana bakery that makes custom event cakes, including wedding cakes, cake pops, pies, cookies, and cupcakes. The business offers free wedding consultations and custom decoration to the couple's specifications.

    Pricing on request

    Retail prices for individual cakes, pies, cookies, cupcakes, and cake pops rather than wedding package or per-serving pricing.

    customclassicfamily-styleevent-focused
    apieceofcakegreenwood.com(317) 887-2253484 N Madison Ave, Greenwood, IN 46142, USA
  • Confectioneiress Cupcakes & Sweets

    Indianapolis

    Confectioneiress Cupcakes & Sweets is a bakery in Zionsville, Indiana that offers wedding cakes, cupcakes, French macarons, cake pops, cream pies, and cookie dough shooters. Couples can build a wedding dessert bar or order one- and two-tier cutting cakes, with all items picked up at the shop.

    Pricing on request

    Pricing is available only by request for a personalized quote.

    moderncustomcreativedessert barcupcake-focusedmacaron
    confectioneiress.com(317) 873-088080 Brendon Way, Zionsville, IN 46077, USA
  • Kim’s Kakery, Bakery & Café

    Indianapolis

    Kim's Kakery is an Indianapolis bakery and café that offers wedding cakes, fully custom cakes, signature cakes, cupcakes, and other baked goods. It provides a wedding cake gallery, design consultations, and options for buttercream or chocolate-based fondant.

    Pricing on request

    Cake pricing is by inquiry, with only minimum purchase requirements mentioned.

    customclassicbuttercreamfondantweddingcafé
    kimskbc.com(317) 784-52535452 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227, USA
  • Sweetkart cakes and Catering llc

    Greenfield

    SweetKart Cakes and Catering is a woman-owned bakery and caterer in Greenfield, Indiana that offers custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and wedding-focused sweet treats. It also provides charcuterie and on-site full-service event catering for weddings and other celebrations.

    Pricing on request
    customsweetsavoryfull-service cateringcelebration
  • The Cakehole

    Indianapolis

    The Cakehole is a family-run bakery in New Palestine, Indiana that makes custom specialty cakes and cupcakes, including wedding cakes. It offers made-from-scratch flavors, a storefront, and delivery options for weddings and other events.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing is by inquiry, while the listed cake, cupcake, delivery, deposit, and rush-order amounts are not explicitly wedding totals.

    customspecialtyfamily-runmade-from-scratchcreative
    thecakehole.net(317) 620-123218 W Main St b, New Palestine, IN 46163, USA
  • Gwendolyn Lee Cakery

    Indianapolis

    Gwendolyn Lee Cakery is a family-owned cake shop in Beech Grove, Indiana that makes custom cakes, cupcakes, and sugar cookies. It offers wedding cakes and wedding consultations by appointment for parties with 100 or more servings.

    Pricing on request
    customfamily-ownedsmall-business
    gwendolynleecakery.com(317) 760-58337 N 5th Ave, Beech Grove, IN 46107, USA
  • Artisan Bakery and Pastries

    Indianapolis

    Artisan Bakery and Pastries is an Indianapolis bakery offering wedding cakes, dessert bars, custom cakes, and a wide range of Mexican and international pastries.

    Pricing on request
    latinomexicaninternationalartisanalcustomartistic
    artisanbakeryinc.com(317) 292-93247341 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46214, USA
  • Brenda's Cakes

    Indianapolis

    Brenda's Cakes and Catering is a Plainfield, Indiana bakery offering wedding cakes, all-occasion cakes, and ready-made sweet treats. Cake consultations and pickup are by appointment at their location inside Toy Buzz & Fizz.

    Pricing on request

    No specific prices are listed; pricing brochures are available for download.

    custom cakesfamily-runlocal bakeryready-made treatscatering
    brendascakes.com(317) 244-12411702 E Main St Ste 101, Plainfield, IN, 46168
  • Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    Indianapolis

    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop is an Indianapolis bakery offering custom cakes, Southern-style desserts, and wedding cakes with a paid consultation and local delivery.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing is by inquiry, while the listed prices are for celebration cakes and fees.

    southerncustomtraditionalbuttercreamfondantcelebration
    cretiacakes.com(317) 929-15604640 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, USA
  • Filigree Bakery

    Indianapolis

    Filigree Bakery is a minority- and woman-owned boutique bakery in Indianapolis offering custom cakes, French macarons, and dessert table options for weddings. The bakery works with a small number of brides each year and offers a tasting experience using signature mini cakes.

    Pricing on request

    Only a non-wedding tasting mini-cake price is listed, and custom cake pricing is not provided.

    boutiqueFrenchcustomdessert-focused
    filigreebakery.com(463) 269-14566331 Carrollton Avenue Indianapolis, IN, 46220 United States
  • Hart Bakery & Gifts

    Indianapolis

    Hart Bakery & Gifts is a family-owned Indianapolis bakery that offers custom wedding cakes in tiered, stair/fountain, and column styles. It also carries traditional baked goods and a gift shop with collectible figurines and dollhouse miniatures.

    Pricing on request
    customeleganttraditionalclassicfamily-owned
    hartbakery.com(317) 357-47067030 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, USA
  • Le Petit Gateau

    Carmel

    Le Petit Gâteau is a Carmel bakery and custom cake studio that offers French-inspired pastries, breads, and event cakes. It is a strong option for couples seeking a custom wedding cake with artistic finishes.

    Pricing on request
    French-inspiredelegantcustomartisticclassicseasonal
    lpgbakery.com(317) 408-5500525 N End Dr, Carmel, IN, 46032
  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Indianapolis

    Nothing Bundt Cakes is an Indianapolis bakery specializing in Bundt cakes, Bundtlets, and Bundtinis, with wedding cakes and event catering available. It offers decorated, tiered, and gluten-free options for celebrations including weddings.

    Pricing on request

    The snippet lists retail sample cake and Bundtini prices plus a catering minimum, not wedding-specific pricing.

    modernelegantcelebratorycolorfulhandcraftedparty-friendly
    nothingbundtcakes.com(317) 559-26328505 Keystone Crossing , Indianapolis, IN, 46240
  • The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, Carmel City Center

    Indianapolis

    The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers at Carmel City Center is an upscale bakery and dining destination offering signature layer cakes, desserts, and wedding/event services.

    Pricing on request

    Starting prices for cakes by style, not explicitly wedding pricing.

    elegantromanticupscalefairytaleluxury
  • Whisk Bakery and Catering

    Greenfield

    Whisk Bakery and Catering is a Greenfield, Indiana bakery and catering business that offers wedding cakes, occasion cakes, and full catering menus for events.

    Pricing on request

    Non-wedding catering add-ons and server fees only.

    bakerycateringcustom cakesoccasion cakeswedding cakes
    whiskbakerycatering.com(815) 981-19892228 Mozart Drive Greenfield Center Township, Greenfield, IN 46140, USA
  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Plainfield

    Nothing Bundt Cakes in Avon, IN is a bakery specializing in Bundt cakes, Bundtlets, Bundtinis, and gluten-free options. It lists wedding cakes among available products and offers catering, delivery, pickup, and curbside service.

    Pricing on request

    Lists retail sample cake prices and a catering minimum order, not wedding cake pricing.

    modernelegantcelebratoryhandcraftedfestive
    nothingbundtcakes.com(317) 973-77169819 E. U.S. Hwy 36 , Avon, IN, 46123
Get your shortlist

Which of these 46 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me