9 cake makers in Bloomington, IN

Two Sticks Bakery is a small, women-owned, from-scratch bakery in Bloomington, Indiana that offers custom cakes and wedding cakes. It provides wedding-specific guidance, pickup-only tastings, and delivery within and around Bloomington.

Only delivery fees are mentioned, and no cake pricing is published.

50 Flavs Bakery & Brew is a local bakery and coffee shop in West Baden Springs and Paoli, Indiana that offers custom cakes, including tiered and elaborate wedding cakes. They also provide catering and dessert spreads for weddings and other celebrations.

Jenny’s Baking Co is a Bloomington, IN bakery offering custom cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, and cookies for weddings and other events. It includes tiered cake options, a bridal cake tasting, and add-ons such as fresh florals and edible printed images.

Lists retail cake and tasting prices rather than a published wedding cake total or per-serving price.

Little Black Dog Bakery is a Bloomington, Indiana bakery offering made-to-order cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes, and other pastries for weddings and other celebrations. It offers wedding-friendly options such as custom lettering, toppers, a two-tier cake, and a wedding cake tasting box.

Lists whole-cake prices by size/tier and a tasting box, with no published per-serving or wedding package pricing.

Magic Morning Bakery is a family-owned Bedford, Indiana bakery known for scratch-made pastries and custom cakes, including custom wedding cakes.

No specific pricing is listed, only a general statement that items are reasonably priced.

Offbeet Bakery is a small, from-scratch bakery in Nashville, Indiana that welcomes wedding and custom cake orders.

Rainbow Bakery is a Bloomington, IN bakery that takes custom cake orders for celebrations and also sells cupcakes, donuts, cookies, muffins, and other baked goods. It is a useful option for couples wanting a flexible, allergen-conscious dessert vendor with short-notice cake availability.

No base cake pricing is listed, only a $10 customization add-on is mentioned.

Spellbound Sweets LLC is a home-based bakery in Seymour, Indiana that makes homemade cakes, pies, cookies, and other treats with whimsical, rustic flavor names. It accepts custom orders for special occasions and offers sugar-free options.

Sample retail menu prices for individual baked goods, not wedding cake pricing.

CayPops Bakery is a custom dessert business in Columbus, IN and Bowling Green, KY specializing in cake pops and sugar cookies for celebrations. Its themed offerings include bridal showers, making it a possible option for wedding dessert treats.