The Wedding Dossier · Wedding Cakes · Indiana

8 cake makers in Evansville, IN

8 cake makers around Evansville and Newburgh, Vincennes, Washington, each checked against its own website and verified as a wedding business. Not a top ten.

1 of them (13%) publish their pricing. Their listings show the real numbers. The other 7 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Evansville cake maker we're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it. Is one of these your business? See your listing and certify it.

The Evansville cake makers list

Showing 8 of 8 cake makers

  • Piece of Cake

    Evansville

    Piece of Cake is an Evansville bakery that offers wedding cakes and cupcakes with classic and custom design options. It provides per-serving wedding pricing and a dedicated wedding inquiry form.

    $3/serving – $4/serving
    • Cupcakes: Starting at $2.75 per serving
    • Wedding Cakes: Starting at $3.75 per serving
    moderntraditionalclassiccustomfloralcolorful
    pieceofcakebakery.com(812) 424-2253210 Main St, Evansville, IN 47708, USA

  • Bea Sweet Treats

    Newburgh

    Bea Sweet Treats is a Newburgh, Indiana bakery offering custom cakes, cupcakes, and dessert catering for weddings and other celebrations. The business has a dedicated wedding inquiry process with in-person or to-go tasting options.

    Pricing on request

    Only tasting fees and retail cake/item prices are listed, with no published wedding cake package or per-serving pricing.

    customfamily-ownedclassicflavor-focusedcelebration
    beasweettreats.com(812) 454-77284111 Merchant Dr, Newburgh, IN 47630, USA

  • Kali’s Bake Adventures

    Vincennes

    Kali’s Bake Adventures is a Vincennes, Indiana bakery offering custom cakes, cupcakes, macarons, cookies, and cake pops, with a dedicated wedding gallery and custom order pricing page.

    Pricing on request

    Custom and retail per-dozen or individual dessert item pricing, not wedding cake pricing.

    customlocaldessert-focusedbuttercreamflavor-forward
    kalisbakeadventures.com(812) 887-98602425 N 6th St, Vincennes, IN 47591, USA

  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Evansville

    Nothing Bundt Cakes in Evansville is a bakery specializing in Bundt cakes, Bundtlets, and Bundtinis, with wedding cakes listed among available products. It offers decorated and tiered Bundt options, event catering, and local delivery for celebrations.

    Pricing on request

    Sample Bundtini product prices and a catering minimum, not wedding-specific pricing.

    modernelegantcelebratorycolorfuldessert-forward
    nothingbundtcakes.com(812) 758-78566436 E. Florida St Suite 100, Evansville, IN, 47715

  • Gingers Home Bakery

    Washington

    Ginger's Home Bakery is a Washington, Indiana bakery offering custom tiered cakes, cupcakes, decorated sugar cookies, and French macarons. It is a local cake and dessert option for weddings and other celebrations.

    Pricing on request

    Retail bakery item prices with no explicit wedding cake or per-serving pricing.

    customhome bakerydecoratedfamily-stylecelebration
    gingershomebakery.com(812) 698-8426

  • Cookie bite pastry - Variety changes daily

    Evansville

    Cookie Bite Pastry is a locally owned Evansville, Indiana bakery offering pre-order pastries, cheesecakes, and mousse cakes. It is pickup-only and may be useful for couples looking for a dessert or cake option.

    Pricing on request

    Retail prices for individual pastries and small cakes, not wedding package or per-serving pricing.

    moderndessert-focusedpastrylocalpre-order
    cookiebitepastry.com(812) 706-54302021 W Franklin St, Evansville, IN 47712, USA

  • Cookies & Cupcake by Design

    Evansville

    Cookies by Design is a cookie and dessert gift company that offers cookie bouquets, baskets, trays, cookie cakes, and custom decorated cookies. It is relevant to weddings mainly for wedding favors, bridal shower favors, and dessert-style cookie presentations.

    Pricing on request

    Retail gift pricing only, with custom and corporate orders handled by contact; no wedding pricing is published.

    customgift-focuseddecoratedplayfulpersonalized
    cookiesbydesign.com(855) 266-5437

  • The Treats & Sweets Co. LLC

    Vincennes

    A small-batch bakery in Vincennes, Indiana that makes custom-decorated sugar cookies and seasonal human sweets, alongside a separate dog-treat line. It is a possible option for custom wedding cookie favors or dessert accents rather than a traditional wedding cake.

    Pricing on request

    Retail cookie pricing by dozen or half dozen, not wedding cake pricing.

    customhandmadesmall-batchcozyplayfulseasonal
    thetreatsandsweetsco.com(812) 899-61101691 Hart St, Vincennes, IN 47591, USA
Get your shortlist

Which of these 8 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me