20 cake makers in Toledo, OH

20 cake makers around Toledo and Sylvania, Findlay, Defiance, Tiffin, Fremont and 2 more nearby towns, each checked against its own website and verified as a wedding business. Not a top ten.

2 of them (10%) publish their pricing. Their listings show the real numbers. The other 18 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Toledo cake maker we're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it. Is one of these your business? See your listing and certify it.

Wedding Cakes pricing in Ohio
Typical per-serving range
$4/serving–$5/serving
Market range
$4/serving–$10/serving
Publish pricing
18of 262

Wedding cake bakers in Ohio typically charge $4 to $5 per serving, with the broader market reaching up to $10 per serving. These figures come only from vendors who publish pricing openly; premium and luxury bakers generally require an inquiry, so the true average cost is likely higher than what the numbers above suggest.

The Toledo cake makers list

Showing 20 of 20 cake makers
  • Dollop Shop

    Toledo

    Dollop Shop is a woman-owned Toledo bakery offering custom wedding cakes and curated dessert bars with a boutique, collaborative design process. They take on a limited number of weddings each year and provide local delivery and setup.

    from $4/serving
    • Wedding cakes: $4 per serving · simple, single-tier designs with minimal decoration
    • Wedding desserts: between $300 and $3,000 · guest headcount, dessert variety, and design complexity
    • Fee: Delivery, setup, and platter rental: $100 · within 30 minutes of West Toledo shop
    • Add-on: Additional drive time: $50 per half hour · locations outside 30-minute radius
    • Fee: Tasting: $50 · seated tasting in shop with coffee or tea
    modernromanticboutiqueelevatedartisancustom
    dollopshoptoledo.com(567) 315-87693144 Markway Road Toledo, OH, 43606 United States
  • Haas Bakery

    Toledo

    Haas Bakery is a local Oregon, Ohio bakery that offers custom wedding cakes with a wide selection of flavors and fillings. Wedding cakes are priced by the serving, with delivery available upon request.

    $2/serving – $5/serving
    • Wedding cake: $2.00 a serving · start price, based on flavors, decor and design
    • Wedding cake: $4.50 a serving · range up to, based on flavors, decor and design
    customtraditionalhandmadelocalflavor-forward
    haas-bakery.com(419) 698-20002306 Starr Ave, Oregon, OH 43616, USA
  • 7 Little Cupcakes

    Toledo

    7 Little Cupcakes is a women-owned bakery in Perrysburg, Ohio that creates custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, and dessert displays for couples in Northwest Ohio and Southeast Michigan.

    Pricing on request

    No specific pricing is listed; only payment terms are mentioned.

    customartisticpersonalizedromanticmoderncupcake-focused
    7littlecupcakes.com(419) 252-0858122 W South Boundary St, Perrysburg, OH 43551, USA
  • Eston's Bakery

    Toledo

    Eston's Bakery is a family-owned Toledo bakery that offers dessert-style wedding cakes with multiple tiered packages and add-on options. It is a strong fit for couples who want a local cake vendor with a dedicated wedding inquiry process and home-tasting option.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake package pricing is deferred to the website, while the listed amounts are for non-wedding cakes and tastings.

    dessert-styleclassicelegantmodernsemi-nakedlocal
    estonsbakery.com(419) 885-94425433 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
  • McKiddy Cakes

    Sylvania

    McKiddy Cakes is a Sylvania, Ohio specialty bakery offering custom wedding cakes, dessert bars, and made-to-order desserts for weddings and special events.

    Pricing on request
    customelegantspecialtymade-from-scratch
    mckiddycakes.com(419) 250-07886904 Oakshade Rd, Sylvania, OH 43560, USA
  • Bee Tree Bakery

    Findlay

    Bee Tree Bakery is a Findlay, Ohio bakery offering custom cakes, wedding cakes, dessert tables, cupcakes, and everyday baked treats. It is a local cake option for couples who want a custom celebration cake or dessert display.

    Pricing on request
    customelegantclassiccelebrationdelicatebespoke
    beetreebakery.com(419) 502-9635118 E Sandusky St, Findlay, OH 45840, USA
  • Simply Sarah's Cakes

    Defiance

    Simply Sarah's Cakes is a Defiance, Ohio home bakery offering custom cakes and cupcakes for weddings, graduations, and other special events. The business uses homemade buttercream frosting and is fondant-free.

    Pricing on request

    Cake pricing is available by inquiry or quote based on a specific design.

    customone-of-a-kindbuttercreamfondant-freehome bakerycreative
    simplysarahscakes.com(419) 576-8202309 Colleen Drive, Defiance, OH, 43512
  • So Sweet Lebanese & French Pastries

    Toledo

    So Sweet Lebanese & French Pastries is a Toledo bakery offering wedding cakes, sweets tables, and event catering with a focus on French and Lebanese pastries.

    Pricing on request
    FrenchLebanesecustom cakesdessert tableevent catering
    sosweetpastries.com(419) 474-54454038 Talmadge Rd, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
  • Wixey Bakery

    Toledo

    Wixey Bakery is a family-owned Toledo bakery that specializes in wedding cakes and other custom baked goods. It offers a tasting before placing an order and is known for flexible cake sizing and pickup timing.

    Pricing on request
    traditionalclassicfamily-ownedhand-craftedneighborhood
    wixeybakerytoledo.com(419) 382-66842017 Glendale Ave, Toledo, OH 43614, USA
  • Elizabeth's Special Day

    Toledo

    Elizabeth's Special Day is a family-owned Toledo bakery offering wedding cakes, cupcakes, and pastry tables for weddings and other events. Wedding consultations and cake tastings are available by appointment.

    Pricing on request

    The only published prices are below realistic wedding cake per-serving levels, so no usable wedding pricing is extracted.

    customfamily-ownedbudget-friendlydessert-focused
    cakeselizabeths.com(419) 376-94985053 N Summit St, Toledo, OH 43611, USA
  • Bakery Unlimited

    Toledo

    Bakery Unlimited is a Toledo-area scratch bakery offering decorated cakes, cupcakes, and custom baked goods, with owner experience in wedding cake decoration.

    Pricing on request
    homemadecustomtraditionalfamily-styledecorated
    bakeryunlimited.com(419) 472-70984427 Secor Rd, Toledo, OH 43623, USA
  • Cookiecuterie

    Toledo

    Cookiecuterie is a Toledo, OH bakery that offers fresh cookies, macarons, chocolate-covered strawberries, and custom cookie trays for weddings and other events.

    Pricing on request
    customfresh-bakedcookie-focuseddessert-tablelocal-bakery
  • Stucky's Old Oak Farm

    Tiffin

    Stucky's Old Oak Farm is a family farm bakery offering gourmet cupcakes, custom cakes, dessert trays, and catering for weddings and other special events.

    Pricing on request

    Lists retail prices for cupcakes, whole cakes, and eggs without explicit wedding pricing.

    farmhouserusticgourmetfamily-ownedcustom
    stuckysoldoakfarm.com(419) 561-32557789 OH-19, Bloomville, OH 44818, USA
  • Cookie Lady

    Fremont

    The Cookie Lady is a locally owned Ohio bakery that makes fresh cookies and personalized frosted cutout cookies, including custom cookie cakes for weddings and other events.

    Pricing on request
    custompersonalizedfresh-bakedcookie-focusedlocally owned
    cookie-lady.com(419) 332-24232480 W State St, Fremont, OH 43420, USA
  • Kendra's Cakes

    Tiffin

    Kendra's Cakes is a small Bascom, Ohio bakery that makes custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and other desserts for weddings and other celebrations. Orders are placed by phone, email, or Facebook, and the bakery recommends ordering about two weeks in advance.

    Pricing on request

    Retail prices for individual cakes, cookie cakes, pies, cheesecakes, and cookies rather than wedding pricing.

    customhand-decoratedthemedclassicplayful
  • The Cakewalk Cakery

    Napoleon

    The Cakewalk Cakery is a small family-owned bakery in Napoleon, Ohio that has made cakes and cupcakes for special occasions, including weddings, since 2011.

    Pricing on request

    Individual round and sheet cake prices are listed, with no explicit wedding cake pricing.

    family-ownedlocalclassiccustomizable
  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Toledo

    Nothing Bundt Cakes in Toledo-Sylvania is a bakery offering Bundt cakes, Bundtlets, Bundtinis, and wedding cakes for pickup or local delivery.

    Pricing on request

    The text lists sample cake prices and non-wedding minimum order amounts rather than wedding cake pricing.

    moderncelebratorydecoratedtieredflavor-forwardgluten-free options
    nothingbundtcakes.com(419) 877-37557427 W. Central Avenue , Toledo, OH, 43617
  • Sur Le Pouce

    Perrysburg

    Sur Le Pouce is a French-style bakery in Perrysburg, Ohio offering breads, pastries, macarons, tarts, and event dessert options for weddings and other gatherings.

    Pricing on request

    The text lists retail menu and event item prices only, with no published wedding cake package or per-serving pricing.

    Frenchartisanalbakeryevent-friendlyelegant
    surlepouceohio.com(336) 508-7665122 W South Boundary St, Perrysburg, OH, 43551
  • Cookie Lady

    Perrysburg

    The Cookie Lady is a locally owned Ohio bakery specializing in fresh cookies and custom frosted cutout cookies. It offers made-to-order cookie options for weddings and other celebrations.

    Pricing on request
    customclassiclocalfresh-bakedcookie-focused
    cookie-lady.com(419) 332-24231647 Toll Gate Dr, Maumee, OH 43537, USA
  • sad snacks

    Toledo

    Sad Snacks is a Toledo bakery specializing in custom sugar cookies that can be used for weddings as dessert table treats, place settings, or party favors.

    Pricing on request

    Retail per-dozen sugar cookie prices with no wedding-specific pricing.

    playfulcustomhandmadecasualquirkypersonalized
Get your shortlist

Which of these 20 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me