16 cake makers in Lancaster, PA

16 cake makers around Lancaster and Millersville, Elizabethtown, Manheim, Mount Joy, Ephrata and 1 more nearby town, each checked against its own website and verified as a wedding business. Not a top ten.

0 of them (0%) publish their pricing. Their listings show the real numbers. The other 16 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.

Know a Lancaster cake maker we're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it. Is one of these your business? See your listing and certify it.

Wedding Cakes pricing in Pennsylvania
Typical per-serving range
$6/serving–$7/serving
Market range
$3/serving–$16/serving
Publish pricing
24of 276

Wedding cake bakers in Pennsylvania typically charge $6 to $7 per serving, with the broader market ranging from $3 to $16 per serving. Because premium and luxury bakers rarely publish prices and require direct inquiry, these figures reflect only transparent vendors, meaning the true average cost is likely higher.

The Lancaster cake makers list

Showing 16 of 16 cake makers
  • Bella Manse

    Millersville

    Bella Manse is a custom wedding cake business serving the Lancaster, PA area with personalized designs for weddings. The site highlights palette knife floral, vintage piped, and classic cake styles.

    Pricing on request

    Only tasting, deposit, and delivery fees are listed, with no usable wedding cake pricing.

    customfloralpalette knifevintagepipedclassic
    bellamanse.com(717) 871-6860138 W Frederick St, Millersville, PA 17551, USA
  • Barton's Flowers & Bake Shop, INC.

    Elizabethtown

    Barton's Flowers & Bake Shop is an Elizabeth, PA bakery and flower shop offering custom wedding cakes, cookie and dessert tables, and wedding florals. Couples can book in-person consultations and receive a complimentary cake tasting.

    Pricing on request

    No pricing is listed; only a free wedding cake tasting is mentioned.

    minimalistelegantvintagetailoredthemeddessert-table
    bartonsbakeshop.com(412) 384-9370311 S 2nd Ave, Elizabeth, PA 15037, USA
  • House of Clarendon

    Lancaster

    House of Clarendon is a Lancaster, PA bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and specialty desserts. They offer private wedding cake consultations and tastings, with wedding service across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, and New York.

    Pricing on request

    Published prices are for general all-occasion cakes, with no explicit wedding cake dollar amounts.

    custompersonalizedintricatetimelessmodernshow-stopping
    houseofclarendon.com(717) 290-7800240 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603, USA
  • Rosie's Creative Cakes

    Manheim

    Rosie's Creative Cakes is a Manheim, PA cake studio specializing in custom wedding cakes and special-occasion cakes. The business offers consultations and tastings as part of the wedding cake planning process.

    Pricing on request
    customclassicromanticnature-inspiredfashion-inspired
    rosiescreativecakes.com(717) 898-91562385 Junction Rd, Manheim, PA 17545, USA
  • Bailey’s Bake Shoppe

    Lancaster

    Bailey’s Bake Shoppe is a family-run Lancaster County bakery that offers custom cakes, wedding cakes, cupcakes, pastries, and other desserts baked fresh in-house.

    Pricing on request
    customfamily-runfresh-bakedLancaster County
    baileysbakeshoppe.com(717) 229-65746 Beaver Valley Pike, Willow Street, PA, 17584
  • Byers Butterflake Bakery

    Lancaster

    Byers Butterflake Bakery is a family-run bakery in Leola, PA that offers wedding cakes with custom designs, a dedicated wedding cake pastry chef, and free consultations. It is part of a broader bakery that also makes everyday cakes, pastries, pies, and other baked goods.

    Pricing on request

    Wedding cake pricing is not listed; only general whole-cake prices are provided.

    customtraditionalfamily-runelaborateromantic
    byersbakery.com(717) 656-680344 W Main St, Leola, PA 17540, USA
  • Geneva Bakery

    Lancaster

    Geneva Bakery is a Lancaster County bakery in East Petersburg that makes custom cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, and dessert bars for weddings and other celebrations. Brides can call to order made-from-scratch cakes with a preferred one-week lead time.

    Pricing on request

    Pricing is available by phone inquiry only, with no published amounts.

    custommade-from-scratchbuttercreamhome-styleLancaster Countybudget-friendly
    genevabakery.com(717) 569-59196030 Lemon St, East Petersburg, PA 17520, USA
  • La Dolce Vita Courthouse Bakery

    Lancaster

    La Dolce Vita Courthouse Bakery is a traditional Italian bakery in downtown Lancaster that offers custom wedding cakes, fillings, frostings, and cookie or biscotti trays for receptions.

    Pricing on request

    No pricing details are provided; the vendor directs customers to call or visit for more information.

    traditionalItaliancustomfamily-runbakerydowntown
    ladolcevitalancaster.com(717) 239-51019 N Duke St, Lancaster, PA 17602, USA
  • Rise Bake Shoppe and Coffee Bar

    Mount Joy

    Rise Bake Shoppe is a Mount Joy, PA scratch-made bakery offering wedding cakes, tiered cakes, cupcakes, macarons, and miniature desserts for celebrations. Couples can schedule a tasting and request custom designs for weddings and special events.

    Pricing on request

    No dollar amounts are provided; pricing is described as based on size, servings, detail, complexity, and time.

    customscratch-madebuttercreamthemedmodernwhimsical
    risebakeshoppe.com(717) 492-8440740 E Main Street Mount Joy, PA USA
  • Scratch Bakes

    Ephrata

    Scratch Bakes is a Pennsylvania bakery and cafe offering made-from-scratch cakes, cupcakes, decorated orders, and event-related baking services. It lists a Weddings section, making it relevant for couples looking for a local cake or dessert vendor.

    Pricing on request

    Delivery fee schedule only; no wedding cake pricing published.

    handcraftedfreshmade-from-scratchdecoratedcafecustom
  • The Flour Child

    Ephrata

    The Flour Child is a custom bakery in Columbia, PA that offers cakes, cupcakes, cookies, pies, and other desserts, with a dedicated weddings section for custom cake orders.

    Pricing on request
    customlocalbakeryappointment-onlywedding cakes
  • The Market at Oregon Dairy

    Lititz

    The Bake Shoppe at Oregon Dairy in Lititz, PA offers custom wedding cakes and cupcakes with a consultation, tastings, and delivery/set-up options.

    Pricing on request

    The snippet lists a deposit, delivery/set-up charges, and retail dessert tray prices rather than published wedding cake pricing.

    customfarm-to-tablelocalrusticclassic
    oregondairy.com(717) 656-28562900 Oregon Pike, Lititz, PA 17543, USA
  • Nothing Bundt Cakes

    Lancaster

    Nothing Bundt Cakes in Lancaster is a Bundt cake bakery that lists wedding cakes as an available product and offers event catering with delivery and pickup.

    Pricing on request

    The text lists retail Bundtini item prices and a catering minimum without explicit wedding cake pricing.

    moderncelebratorydecoratedtieredflavor-forwardevent-friendly
    nothingbundtcakes.com(717) 490-71211500 Gilbert Way Suite B117, Lancaster, PA, 17601
  • Erica Joy Bakes

    Lititz

    Erica Joy Bakes is a certified gluten-free bakery in downtown Lititz, PA that offers custom cakes, cupcakes, and other baked goods for weddings and special events.

    Pricing on request

    Retail pick-up menu pricing for cakes, cupcakes, and baked goods rather than wedding-specific pricing.

    gluten-freeallergy-consciouscustomseasonalsmall-batch
    ericajoybakes.com(717) 553-274777 E Main St, Lititz, PA 17543, USA
  • The Urban Farmhouse

    Lancaster

    The Urban Farmhouse is a Lancaster, PA cheesecake bakery offering traditional, seasonal, and gluten-friendly cheesecakes. It is a potential wedding cake or dessert option for couples seeking a cheesecake-focused vendor.

    Pricing on request
    rusticfarmhousehomemadecheesecake-focused
  • Vécu

    Lancaster

    Vécu is a modern French-inspired bistro and bakery in Lancaster, PA, with a patisserie-focused bakery menu and special events/catering contact information.

    Pricing on request
    modernFrenchbistrobakerypatisserieupscale
    26eastlancaster.com(717) 690-235426 E King St, Lancaster, PA 17602, USA
Get your shortlist

Which of these 16 fit your budget?

Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.

Rank these for me