12 cake makers in Columbia, SC
We tracked down 30 possible cake makers around Columbia and Lexington, Irmo, then checked each one against its own website. These are the 12 we could verify. Not a top ten, and not a paid directory.
4 of them (33%) publish their pricing. Those are listed first with the real numbers. The other 8 quote on request, which is normal in this industry, so plan on contacting several to compare.
Know a Columbia cake makerwe're missing, or spot something wrong on a listing? Tell us and we'll fix it.
The Columbia cake makers list
Bakin' It Cakes & Sweets, LLC
LexingtonBakin' It Cakes & Sweets is a home-based cakery in Lexington, SC specializing in custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, and signature desserts made with homemade buttercream. They offer wedding inquiry services and deliver to Lexington and surrounding areas.
$5/serving – $13/servingSignature wedding cakes priced by whole cake ($58–$90 for 7-inch serving up to 12); per-serving range derived from cake prices.
homemadecustombuttercreamelegantSweet Paradise
ColumbiaSweet Paradise is a luxury wedding cake shop in Irmo, SC, founded in 2011 by Kemperlyn Graham, specializing in custom-designed cakes with hand-crafted sugar flowers and exquisite artistry.
from $900Wedding cake starting price of $900; tasting fee is non-refundable but credits toward purchase.
luxuryelegantartisticcustomexquisiteChocolate Wonderland
LexingtonChocolate Wonderland is a 30-year-old cake and chocolate specialty shop offering custom wedding cakes, cupcakes, and personalized candy for weddings and events. They provide affordable pricing, local delivery, and setup services.
from $259Wedding cake starting price for 3-tier cake; delivery charge not included.
elegantchocolate-focusedcustomizableButterKreme Queen Bakery
IrmoButterKreme Queen Bakery is a small-batch, scratch bakery specializing in custom wedding cakes and catering for events. Owner Jackie Bradley brings formal culinary training and a passion for modern cake design with traditional roots.
from $500Custom cakes start at $150 (non-wedding retail); event catering has $500 minimum (wedding-relevant).
moderntraditionalartisanalsmall-batchCakes by Jan
ColumbiaCakes by Jan is a custom cake and cupcake bakery in South Carolina specializing in personalized designs for celebrations. They offer traditional, gluten-free, dairy-free (vegan), and diabetic cake options.
Pricing on requestStrossner's Bakery, Cafe & Deli
LexingtonStrossner's Bakery is a family-owned Greenville bakery since 1947 offering custom wedding cakes and decorative cakes in various flavors and sizes. Named the #4 Best Bakery in the South by Southern Living, they provide 24-hour ordering with local delivery and in-store pickup.
Pricing on requestRetail cake pricing by size; no wedding-specific pricing or per-serving rates stated.
traditionalclassiccustomSouthernIan's Sweet Treats Baskets and More
ColumbiaIan's Sweet Treats Baskets and More is a handmade dessert shop in Columbia, SC specializing in custom cakes and gourmet desserts. They offer custom 6-inch 3-layer cakes starting at $150 and operate by appointment only.
Pricing on requestIndividual retail item pricing for cakes and confections; no wedding-specific or per-serving cake pricing stated.
artisanalhandmadegourmetians-sweet-treats-baskets-and-more.ueniweb.com+180384934041133 Colleton St., Columbia, South Carolina, 29203Kudzu Bakery & Market Columbia
ColumbiaKudzu Bakery & Market Columbia is a Southern bakery offering a variety of custom cakes and desserts with an emphasis on quality and simple, elegant design. They serve the Columbia, SC area and accept custom orders by phone.
Pricing on requestsouthernelegantartisanalclassicNothing Bundt Cakes
ColumbiaNothing Bundt Cakes is a specialized bakery offering Bundt cakes in multiple sizes and flavors with signature cream cheese frosting. They explicitly list wedding cakes as an available product and offer catering services with delivery.
Pricing on requestmodernelegantcontemporarycustomizableThe Yummy Cakery
LexingtonThe Yummy Cakery is a family-owned bakery in Lexington, SC that specializes in custom cakes and cupcakes made from scratch with high-quality ingredients. They offer celebration cakes and cupcakes by the dozen, making them a viable option for wedding desserts.
Pricing on requestartisanalhomemadeclassicCarolina Girl Confections
ColumbiaCarolina Girl Confections is a homemade bakery in Columbia, SC specializing in Southern heirloom cakes made from scratch by appointment. While they focus on traditional Southern flavors and styles, they do not explicitly market wedding cakes as a primary service.
Pricing on requestRetail cake and cupcake pricing; Southern Heirloom Cakes $50–$60, Mason Jar Cakes $55–$57 (qty 5), Cupcakes $30/dozen.
traditionalSouthernhomemadenostalgicrusticKaminsky's Dessert Cafe
ColumbiaKaminsky's Dessert Café is a dessert-focused establishment with locations in Charleston and Columbia, SC, offering daily-made desserts, specialty beverages, and alcohol. They offer whole dessert orders suitable for events and celebrations.
Pricing on requestcozycasualcontemporary
Which of these 12 fit your budget?
Tell us your budget, your area, and your guest count, and we'll rank every vendor on this page against it. About a minute, no account needed to see your matches.
Rank these for me